Which hospital is safer?

Question

Two hospitals report patient survival, split by how sick patients were on arrival.

Hospital A: 90 of 100 mild patients survive (90%), and 200 of 400 severe patients survive (50%).
Hospital B: 800 of 900 mild patients survive (88.9%), and 40 of 100 severe patients survive (40%).

Hospital A has the higher survival rate for mild patients and for severe patients. Yet hospital B has the higher overall survival rate.

Show that hospital B has the higher overall survival rate, and give that rate. Which hospital would you choose as a patient?

Accepted Answer

Within each severity group, A wins: mild 90\% to 88.9\%, severe 50\% to 40\%. So for any individual patient, A gives a better chance. Now pool each hospital's patients. 	ext{Hospital A overall} = \frac{90+200}{100+400} = \frac{290}{500} = 58\%. 	ext{Hospital B overall} = \frac{800+40}{900+100} = \frac{840}{1000} = 84\%. Hospital B looks safer overall, 84\% to 58\%, yet it is worse for both mild and severe patients. The explanation is patient mix. Hospital A is a specialist center treating mostly severe cases (400 of 500), whose survival is low no matter where they go, so A's overall rate is…

Which hospital is safer?

Your answer

More Probability questions